Crowe MacKay LLP Employee Reviews

Sort by: Helpfulness | Rating | Date
Job Work/Life Balance
Salary/Benefits
Job Security/Advancement
Management
Job Culture
Terrible
Supervisor (Former Employee) –  Yellowknife, NT18 October 2015
Like most of us, we chose to go to Yellowknife for the adventure, and for the higher salary. Generally speaking, most get recruited from the East, but this was not my case.

I was a Supervisor for a while, but do caution anyone who may choose to work for MacKay Yellowknife.

In your first year of working for MacKay, you will owe the company on average $9000. It is normal practice for CA firms to add the cost of modules on a forgivable 1 or 2 year loan. What is not normal, is to add the cost of Junior staff member 'in house' required training they send you on in the South. Add your initial travel to Yellowknife, one or two modules, -you get the picture. If you leave, they will just keep your pay and offer you no other way to reimburse.. this is also not normal.

Retention in any CA firm is not great, but MacKay Yellowknife has taken this to another level. They will blame retention on the north, but the majority of designated accountants who have left them will still be working in Yellowknife.

I have never worked at a place with such a dark culture. It was a terrible place to work for, and I should have decided to leave much sooner than I did.

I highly recommend anyone considering MacKay Yellowknife to get in contact with a former employee over Linked In. There must be a better option for you out there, especially with this CPA merger. You don't need CATO time, so do yourself a favour and pass on this "opportunity"
Pros
Higher salary
Cons
Poor firm culture
Was this review helpful?Yes 19No 15Report
Job Work/Life Balance
Salary/Benefits
Job Security/Advancement
Management
Job Culture
Endless Opportunities, Skilled and Knowledgeable Staff, CPA/CA Support, Continuous Development
Supervisor (Current Employee) –  Yellowknife9 October 2015
Originally recruited from the East Coast, I saw the potential for adventure and opportunity in the North and have never looked back on my decision.

I originally began my career with Crowe MacKay LLP as an articling student in 2012 and have continued to work with the Company for the past three years, now a Supervisor.

The opportunities I have been given to grow within the firm have been invaluable. The skills and knowledge I have gained over the past three years have made me a rounded Professional. I have grown to be able to provide valuable support to clients and staff members alike to help businesses grow and see other individuals succeed in the accounting field. I have been given opportunities to work in a wide variety areas, including for-profit, not-for-profit, financial services, consulting, tax and government projects alike. I have also been provided with the opportunity to travel the North exploring many parts of the Northwest Territories and Nunavut.

Crowe MacKay has gone above and beyond my expectations as a articling student to ensure that I was given all the support and guidance through the CASB process. Ultimately I was able to pass all six modules and the UFE on the first time which is attributable to both the support of Crowe MacKay and my personal work ethics which were supported by their values.

Completing the CASB/CPA courses is always going to be a daunting task to create work/life balance. Crowe MacKay LLP provides all CASB/CPA students with support through this process with experienced mentors who have recently completed the process themselves
  more... and are able to guide and assist through the process. Crowe MacKay truly wants everyone to succeed through this process and the time and monetary support provided are outstanding.

Beyond the CASB/CPA process, Crowe MacKay continuously develops their staff and continues to invest in their growth. Crowe MacKay has provided me with extensive professional training and support to ensure that professional standards are adhered to and I am up to date on changing professional standards.

Crowe MacKay LLP has created a culture based on their values and beliefs of caring, sharing, investing and growing in both their staff and clients. The Yellowknife Office hosts many staff events on an annual basis which assists in creating and maintaining a team environment where members are committed, supportive and respectful.

I continuously feel supported by management and staff alike and feel my work is valuable to the Company as a whole. While no one ever said a career in accounting would be easy, Crowe MacKay LLP sure does make it worth it!
  less
Pros
CPA Support, Staff Events, Fair Wages, Supportive Staff, Potential for Growth
Cons
Busy Season, Long Hours
Was this review helpful?Yes 11No 14Report
Job Work/Life Balance
Salary/Benefits
Job Security/Advancement
Management
Job Culture
Yellowknife's Revolving Door
Staff Accountant (Former Employee) –  Yellowknife, NT24 April 2015
I worked for MacKay Yellowknife for a very short time (a couple of months). I was recruited from the East, as the salary in Yellowknife was much higher. Unfortunately, I should have listened to my gut feeling when I read about their 30 min policy for "Cake Day".. in their employment contract... and yes I'm being serious....

An example of their culture, which stands out to this day, was when I received a one-line email in July stating "Tell me why you didn't you obtain 200 chargeable hours, and don't give me a childish excuse".

I obtained 197 chargeable hours as a Junior (3 hours short) and just found out I had passed my first module in the CA program. I was disgusted, in fact, I still have that email, and I show it to students when explaining 'firm culture' to this day.

Anyway, I finished my articling with a different firm.. that actually had CA's that I could learn from, and happily passed the UFE away from that place.

Over the years it's interesting to watch the "well known" Yellowknife MacKay revolving door get good use. Before you choose to go there, do yourself a favour and ask a previous staff member their experience.
Pros
Higher salary than southern firms
Cons
Very poor culture
Was this review helpful?Yes 23No 18Report
Job Work/Life Balance
Salary/Benefits
Job Security/Advancement
Management
Job Culture
Productive, knowledgable and organized mid-sized work place
Accounting Technician (Former Employee) –  Edmonton, Alberta19 July 2014
In a typical day I would encounter a variety of duties, such as:
-preparation of financial statements, both review and notice to readers
-preparation of corporate and personal tax returns
-government remittances
-payroll
-bookkeeping
-client relations
-account reconciliations
-management of AR and AP accounts
-preparation of T4/T5
-some administrative tasks

I learned a great many things here such as review engagements and corporate tax.

Management and my peers were enjoyable and easy to work with.

The hardest part of the job were the long hours required during tax season, however, this benefited me with Fridays off during the summer months.
Pros
Social committee and the office was a learning environment
Cons
Communte to downtown Edmonton
Was this review helpful?Yes 8No 13Report
Job Work/Life Balance
Salary/Benefits
Job Security/Advancement
Management
Job Culture
Okay place to work
Staff accountant, full-time (Former Employee) –  Vancouver, BC6 July 2014
Good to learn as a student. Not a very busy firm, most managers were pretty good to work for.
Was this review helpful?Yes 7No 12Report
Claim this company page

Want to know more about working here?

Ask a question about working or interviewing at Crowe MacKay LLP. Our community is ready to answer.

Ask a Question

Overall rating

3.2
Based on 6 reviews
52
41
31
20
12

Ratings by category

3.0Work/Life Balance
3.8Salary/Benefits
3.5Job Security/Advancement
2.8Management
2.8Culture

Crowe MacKay LLP Reviews by Location